Outline vs Other Notion Alternatives: Compared
Quick Verdict
Outline is the best self-hosted Notion alternative for teams that need a stable, polished knowledge base with real-time collaboration. AppFlowy is better if you need Notion’s database features (kanban, calendar views). AFFiNE is better if you need whiteboards. BookStack is better if you want the simplest setup with built-in authentication.
The Contenders
| App | One-line Description | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Outline | Fast, modern knowledge base with real-time collaboration | Team documentation |
| AppFlowy | Full Notion clone with docs + databases | Notion power users |
| AFFiNE | Docs + whiteboards in one app | Visual thinkers |
| BookStack | Structured wiki (Shelves → Books → Chapters) | Simple team wikis |
| Wiki.js | Git-synced wiki with multiple editors | Developer documentation |
Detailed Comparison
| Feature | Outline | AppFlowy | AFFiNE | BookStack | Wiki.js |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real-time collab | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Database views | No | Table, kanban, calendar, grid | Table, kanban | No | No |
| Whiteboards | No | No | Yes | No | No |
| Built-in auth | No (OIDC required) | GoTrue (email + OAuth) | Email + Google | Yes (email/password) | Yes (email/password) |
| Mobile apps | PWA | Native iOS/Android | Web only | Responsive web | Responsive web |
| Git sync | No | No | No | No | Yes |
| Setup complexity | Medium (3 services + auth) | High (5+ services) | Medium (3+ services) | Low (2 services) | Low (2 services) |
| Maturity | Stable | Growing | Beta | Very stable | Stable (v3 transition) |
| RAM (full stack) | ~500 MB | 2-4 GB | 2-3 GB | ~300 MB | ~400 MB |
Outline’s Strengths
- Editing experience. Outline’s Markdown editor with slash commands is the most fluid of the group. Document creation feels fast and modern.
- Real-time collaboration. Multiple users can edit the same document simultaneously with live cursors. Only AppFlowy and AFFiNE also offer this.
- Search. Outline’s full-text search is fast and accurate, powered by PostgreSQL.
- API. A comprehensive REST API enables automation and integration with other tools.
- Stability. Outline is production-ready. Companies run it for real team documentation today.
Outline’s Weaknesses
- No database views. If you use Notion’s tables, kanbans, or calendar views, Outline doesn’t have them. AppFlowy does.
- No built-in auth. Requires OIDC, Google, Slack, or another OAuth provider. BookStack and Wiki.js have built-in username/password auth.
- No whiteboards. AFFiNE uniquely offers documents + infinite canvas.
- No Git sync. Wiki.js can sync content to a Git repo for version control and backup.
When to Choose Each
Choose Outline When…
You need a polished, stable knowledge base for a team that already has an identity provider (Authentik, Keycloak, Google Workspace). You want the best editing experience and real-time collaboration. You don’t need database views or whiteboards.
Choose AppFlowy When…
You need Notion’s database features — kanban boards, calendar views, relational databases. You want native mobile apps. You’re willing to manage a more complex Docker deployment.
Choose AFFiNE When…
Visual thinking matters. You want documents and whiteboards in one tool. You’re comfortable with beta software and rougher edges.
Choose BookStack When…
You want the simplest possible setup. Built-in auth, two Docker containers, structured organization with books and chapters. Best for small teams that need a wiki without complexity.
Choose Wiki.js When…
You want Git-based content management. Multiple editor types for different team members. Developer documentation where Mermaid diagrams and code blocks are heavily used.
Final Verdict
Outline is the best choice for team knowledge bases when you have an identity provider. It offers the most polished editing experience, real-time collaboration, and a clean UI. It won’t replace every Notion feature (no databases, no whiteboards), but for documentation and knowledge management, it’s the strongest option.
If you need a complete Notion replacement, AppFlowy comes closest. If you want the easiest setup, BookStack wins. Each tool has a clear niche — the right choice depends on which Notion features you actually use.
Related
Get self-hosting tips in your inbox
New guides, comparisons, and setup tutorials — delivered weekly. No spam.