Proxmox vs ESXi vs Unraid: Hardware Needs
Quick Verdict
Proxmox VE is the best choice for most homelabbers. Free, open source, runs on virtually any x86 hardware, supports both VMs and LXC containers, and has excellent ZFS integration. ESXi was the enterprise standard but VMware’s licensing changes under Broadcom (2024) killed the free tier — it’s no longer practical for home use. Unraid is the best for storage-first setups where you want mixed drive sizes with parity protection.
| Platform | License | Best For | Hardware Flexibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proxmox VE | Free (open source) | VMs + containers + ZFS | Runs on anything |
| VMware ESXi | $$ (Broadcom killed free tier) | Enterprise labs | Strict HCL, limited NIC support |
| Unraid | $59–129 (lifetime) | NAS + VMs + Docker | Flexible, any hardware |
Hardware Requirements Compared
CPU Requirements
| Feature | Proxmox VE | ESXi 8 | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Architecture | x86_64 | x86_64 | x86_64 |
| Min cores | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Recommended cores | 8+ | 8+ | 4+ |
| VT-x required | Yes | Yes | Yes (for VMs) |
| VT-d required | For PCI passthrough | For PCI passthrough | For PCI passthrough |
| IOMMU required | For passthrough | For passthrough | For passthrough |
| Intel N100 support | Yes | Not on HCL (may work) | Yes |
| AMD Ryzen support | Yes | Limited (check HCL) | Yes |
| Xeon support | Yes | Yes (primary target) | Yes |
Key difference: ESXi has a strict Hardware Compatibility List (HCL). Consumer NICs (Realtek, some Intel i225/i226) aren’t supported — you may need a community driver VIB or a supported NIC. Proxmox and Unraid run on anything Linux supports.
RAM Requirements
| Spec | Proxmox VE | ESXi 8 | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum | 2 GB | 8 GB | 4 GB |
| Recommended | 32 GB+ | 32 GB+ | 16 GB+ |
| ECC support | Yes (recommended for ZFS) | Yes | Yes |
| Max supported | Platform limit (TB+) | Platform limit | Platform limit |
| RAM for host overhead | 2–4 GB | 4–8 GB | 2–3 GB |
ESXi uses more host RAM than Proxmox because the VMkernel is a heavier hypervisor. On a 32 GB system, ESXi overhead leaves you ~24 GB for VMs. Proxmox overhead leaves ~28 GB.
Unraid is the lightest because it’s primarily a storage OS — virtualization is a secondary feature. But it uses RAM for its array operations (especially when rebuilding parity).
Storage Requirements
| Feature | Proxmox VE | ESXi 8 | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boot drive min | 8 GB | 32 GB (USB boot deprecated) | 2 GB USB (array on separate drives) |
| Filesystem | ext4, XFS, ZFS, Ceph | VMFS, vSAN, NFS | XFS (data), btrfs (cache), custom |
| ZFS support | Native (excellent) | No | Via plugin (limited) |
| Mixed drive sizes | ZFS: same size per vdev | VMFS: yes | Yes (primary feature) |
| Drive pass-through | Yes (PCI + USB) | Yes (RDM, PCI) | Yes (Unassigned Devices plugin) |
| NVMe boot | Yes | Yes (SATA/NVMe required in ESXi 8) | Yes (but array is separate) |
| Software RAID | ZFS, mdadm | No (hardware RAID or vSAN) | Parity (custom implementation) |
Proxmox + ZFS is the gold standard for data integrity. ZFS gives you checksumming, snapshots, compression, and replication built in.
Unraid’s parity system is unique: drives can be different sizes, any single drive can be read independently, and parity protects against drive failure without traditional RAID. The trade-off is slower write speeds (parity calculation) compared to ZFS mirrors.
ESXi with VMFS is fast but doesn’t checksum data. vSAN requires 3+ nodes — overkill for home use.
Network Requirements
| Feature | Proxmox VE | ESXi 8 | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Min NICs | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Recommended NICs | 2 (management + VM traffic) | 2 | 1 (NAS is primary) |
| Realtek support | Yes | No (not on HCL, community VIB needed) | Yes |
| Intel i225/i226 | Yes | Partial (some steppings) | Yes |
| 10GbE support | Any Linux-supported NIC | Intel X520/X710, Mellanox (on HCL) | Any Linux-supported NIC |
| VLAN support | Yes (bridges + VLANs) | Yes (vSwitch) | Yes (via plugins) |
| SR-IOV | Yes | Yes | Limited |
ESXi NIC compatibility is the biggest hardware headache. If your motherboard has a Realtek 2.5GbE NIC (very common), ESXi won’t detect it without a community driver. Proxmox and Unraid use Linux drivers — if Linux supports it, they support it.
Hardware Recommendations by Platform
Best Hardware for Proxmox VE
| Budget | Hardware | Why |
|---|---|---|
| $250 | Beelink EQ12 Pro (N305) + 32 GB | 8 cores, low power, VT-d, QuickSync |
| $400 | Beelink SER5 Max (Ryzen 7 5800H) + 64 GB | 16 threads, serious compute |
| $500 | Used Dell OptiPlex 7090 + 64 GB + HBA | PCIe expansion, drive bays |
| $800 | HP Z440 (Xeon E5-1650 v3) + 128 GB + HBA | Maximum expansion and RAM |
Proxmox runs on everything. No HCL worries. The only hardware consideration is ECC RAM for ZFS (recommended, not required) and VT-d for PCI passthrough.
Best Hardware for ESXi 8
| Budget | Hardware | Why |
|---|---|---|
| $300 | Dell OptiPlex 7080 (i7-10700) + Intel NIC | Intel NIC on HCL, vPro support |
| $500 | HP Z440 + Intel X520-DA2 | Xeon + Intel NIC guaranteed compatibility |
| $600+ | Dell R730 (used) | Enterprise hardware, full HCL support |
For ESXi: stick with Intel. Intel CPUs, Intel NICs, Intel chipsets. VMware’s HCL is Intel-centric. AMD works but check compatibility. Realtek doesn’t work without hacks. If you must use ESXi, budget $20 for an Intel X520-DA2 NIC.
Best Hardware for Unraid
| Budget | Hardware | Why |
|---|---|---|
| $300 | Any mini PC + external DAS | Simple NAS + Docker |
| $500 | DIY ATX build (Ryzen 5600G + 6 SATA) | Multiple drive bays |
| $700 | DIY NAS case (Node 804) + HBA + 4 drives | Proper NAS with parity |
Unraid doesn’t care about hardware. Any x86 system with enough SATA ports works. Unraid boots from USB, so the boot drive doesn’t waste a SATA port. Focus on: drive count (SATA ports + HBA), RAM for Docker containers, and a cache SSD.
Platform Feature Comparison
| Feature | Proxmox VE | ESXi 8 | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| VM management | Web UI (excellent) | vSphere Web Client | Web UI (good) |
| Container support | LXC (native) | None | Docker (native) |
| Clustering | Yes (3+ nodes) | Yes (vCenter, $$$$) | No |
| Live migration | Yes (free) | Yes (requires vCenter) | No |
| Backup | Proxmox Backup Server (free) | Veeam, etc. ($$$) | Built-in (basic) |
| GPU passthrough | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| USB passthrough | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| API | Full REST API | vSphere API | GraphQL + REST |
| Community | Large (forums, Reddit) | Declining (post-Broadcom) | Active (forums, Reddit) |
| Updates | apt (standard Linux) | Lifecycle Manager | Web UI (simple) |
Migration Considerations
From ESXi to Proxmox
Many homelabbers migrated after Broadcom killed ESXi’s free tier in 2024. The migration path:
- Export VMs as OVA/OVF from ESXi
- Import into Proxmox via
qm importovf - Adjust VM settings (BIOS mode, disk controller, NIC driver)
- Test and optimize
Most VMs migrate successfully. Windows VMs may need driver changes (VMware tools → QEMU guest agent). Linux VMs usually work without changes.
From Unraid to Proxmox
If you want ZFS instead of Unraid’s parity:
- Back up all data from Unraid array
- Install Proxmox on the boot drive
- Create ZFS pool with the data drives
- Restore data
- Recreate Docker containers as Proxmox LXC containers or in a Docker VM
From Proxmox to Unraid
If you want simpler storage management:
- Back up VMs with Proxmox Backup Server
- Install Unraid on a USB drive
- Build the array with data drives
- Restore data
- Import VMs via Unraid’s VM manager (uses libvirt/QEMU underneath)
FAQ
Is ESXi dead for home use?
Effectively yes. Broadcom discontinued the free ESXi license, and the cheapest VMware vSphere subscription costs thousands per year. Some homelabbers still run ESXi 8.0 with previously obtained free licenses, but there’s no path forward for new installations without paying enterprise prices.
Can I run Proxmox and Unraid on the same hardware?
Not simultaneously (they’re both bare-metal hypervisors). You could run Unraid as a VM inside Proxmox (some people do this), passing through an HBA to give Unraid direct access to drives. This is complex but functional.
Which is best for a beginner?
Unraid is the easiest to set up and manage. The web UI is polished, Docker integration is simple, and the learning curve is gentle. Proxmox is more powerful but has a steeper learning curve (Linux administration, ZFS concepts, networking). Start with Unraid if you’re primarily interested in NAS + Docker. Start with Proxmox if you want to learn enterprise virtualization.
Do I need 64 GB RAM for virtualization?
Not to start. 32 GB handles 3–5 lightweight VMs comfortably. You need 64 GB if you plan to run Windows VMs (8–16 GB each) or TrueNAS with ZFS (needs RAM for ARC). Start with 32 GB and upgrade when you hit limits.
Related
Get self-hosting tips in your inbox
New guides, comparisons, and setup tutorials — delivered weekly. No spam.