PowerDNS vs CoreDNS: Authoritative DNS Compared
Quick Verdict
PowerDNS is the better choice for hosting authoritative DNS zones with database-backed record management and a REST API. It’s a production-grade DNS server used by hosting providers and ISPs. CoreDNS is better for infrastructure DNS — Kubernetes service discovery, forwarding, and flexible plugin-based configurations. For hosting your own DNS zones, PowerDNS. For container orchestration DNS, CoreDNS.
Overview
PowerDNS is an authoritative DNS server that stores records in databases (MySQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite). It has a comprehensive REST API for managing zones and records programmatically. The PowerDNS ecosystem includes the Authoritative Server, Recursor (recursive resolver), and dnsdist (load balancer). PowerDNS site
CoreDNS is a plugin-based DNS server that’s the default DNS in Kubernetes clusters. It can serve zones from files, forward queries, integrate with service discovery systems, and more. Built with Go as a CNCF graduated project. CoreDNS site
Feature Comparison
| Feature | PowerDNS | CoreDNS |
|---|---|---|
| Authoritative serving | Yes (primary purpose) | Yes (file/auto plugin) |
| Database backends | MySQL, PostgreSQL, SQLite, LDAP, BIND files | Zone files only |
| REST API | Yes (comprehensive) | No (plugin for basic API) |
| Zone transfers (AXFR/IXFR) | Yes (primary + secondary) | Yes (transfer plugin) |
| DNSSEC signing | Yes (full key management) | Plugin-based |
| Dynamic updates (RFC 2136) | Yes | Plugin-based |
| Web UI | PowerDNS-Admin (community) | No |
| Kubernetes integration | No | Yes (native) |
| Plugin architecture | Backends (C++) | Everything is a plugin (Go) |
| Geo DNS | Yes (geoip backend) | Plugin-based |
| Response policy zones | Via Recursor | Plugin |
| Prometheus metrics | Yes | Yes |
| Docker image | powerdns/pdns-auth-* | coredns/coredns |
| Written in | C++ | Go |
| License | GPL-2.0 | Apache-2.0 |
Installation Complexity
PowerDNS requires a database (PostgreSQL or MySQL recommended) and schema initialization. The setup involves creating the database schema, configuring the backend, and optionally setting up PowerDNS-Admin for web management. More complex but provides a proper DNS management platform.
CoreDNS is simpler for basic zone serving — create a zone file, write a minimal Corefile, and start. For Kubernetes, it’s automatically configured by the cluster. Adding features means stacking plugins in the Corefile.
Performance and Resource Usage
| Metric | PowerDNS | CoreDNS |
|---|---|---|
| RAM (idle) | ~50-100 MB | ~15-30 MB |
| RAM (active) | ~100-300 MB | ~30-100 MB |
| Queries per second | 100,000+ | 50,000+ |
| Latency | ~1-2 ms | ~1-2 ms |
| Database | Required (external) | None (file-based zones) |
PowerDNS is designed for high-throughput authoritative DNS. Its database-backed architecture handles millions of records efficiently. CoreDNS is lighter but not optimized for large-scale authoritative serving.
Use Cases
Choose PowerDNS If…
- You’re hosting DNS zones for domains you own
- You need a REST API for programmatic DNS management
- You want database-backed record storage (for automation)
- You need DNSSEC key management
- You’re running a hosting provider or ISP
- You want Geo DNS routing
Choose CoreDNS If…
- You need Kubernetes cluster DNS
- You want flexible DNS forwarding with plugins
- You need service discovery integration
- You prefer file-based zone management
- You want the lightest possible footprint
Final Verdict
PowerDNS for authoritative DNS hosting. If you manage DNS zones for your domains and want API-driven record management, PowerDNS is the professional choice. The database backend enables automation and integration with provisioning systems.
CoreDNS for infrastructure and Kubernetes. As a general-purpose DNS server for containers and microservices, CoreDNS is purpose-built. Its plugin model handles service discovery, forwarding, and caching elegantly.
FAQ
Can CoreDNS replace PowerDNS for authoritative DNS?
For small-scale zone hosting (a few domains), yes. For production DNS with API management, database backends, DNSSEC key rotation, and zone transfers to secondary servers, PowerDNS is significantly more capable.
Does PowerDNS do recursive resolution?
The PowerDNS Recursor is a separate product for recursive resolution. The Authoritative Server handles authoritative queries only. You can run both together.
Which is used in production more?
PowerDNS serves authoritative DNS for major hosting providers and ISPs. CoreDNS serves DNS for most Kubernetes clusters globally. Both are heavily production-tested, but for different use cases.
Related
Get self-hosting tips in your inbox
New guides, comparisons, and setup tutorials — delivered weekly. No spam.