Self-Hosted Amazon Music Alternatives
Why Replace Amazon Music?
Bundled costs obscure the real price. Amazon Music is “included” with Prime ($15/month), but Prime’s price keeps rising. Amazon Music Unlimited costs an additional $9-11/month on top. You’re paying for music whether you realize it or not.
Quality confusion. Amazon has repeatedly changed what’s included at each tier — HD, Ultra HD, Spatial Audio have shuffled between tiers. What you get depends on when you subscribed and which plan you’re on. Self-hosting eliminates tier confusion: your files play at whatever quality they are.
Echo lock-in. Amazon Music is optimized for Alexa and Echo devices. If you leave the Amazon ecosystem, the tight integration disappears. Self-hosted music works with any device.
Privacy. Amazon tracks your listening habits, ties them to your shopping profile, and uses them for advertising. Your music preferences feed Amazon’s data machine.
The Prime trap. Many people keep Prime (and its bundled music) out of inertia. If you’re paying $180/year for Prime mainly for shipping, evaluate whether you actually use Amazon Music — or if a $50 self-hosted setup would serve your music needs better.
Best Alternatives
Navidrome — Best Overall Replacement
Navidrome replaces Amazon Music with a lightweight, self-hosted music server. Point it at your music files and stream to any device via 50+ Subsonic-compatible apps.
Why it replaces Amazon Music: If you have an existing music collection (CDs, digital purchases, FLAC downloads), Navidrome gives you a streaming experience comparable to Amazon Music — browse by artist, album, genre; create playlists; stream to your phone — without paying monthly.
Key advantage over Amazon Music: No quality tiers, no shuffle-only limitations, no ads. Every track plays at the full quality of your source files. FLAC stays FLAC.
[Read our full guide: How to Self-Host Navidrome]
Jellyfin — Best for Amazon Ecosystem Refugees
If you’re leaving the Amazon ecosystem entirely (Prime Video, Music, Photos), Jellyfin replaces all of them with a single self-hosted platform. It handles movies, TV shows, music, books, and photos.
Why it works here: One migration, one server, one solution for all your media. Instead of separate replacements for Prime Video, Amazon Music, and Amazon Photos, Jellyfin handles everything.
[Read our full guide: How to Self-Host Jellyfin]
Plex with Plexamp — Best for Casual Listeners
If Amazon Music was your background-listening service — something playing while you work — Plexamp creates that same experience from your own library. Sonic analysis builds auto-playlists, and the UI is clean and distraction-free.
Cost: Plex Pass is $5/month or $120 lifetime. Even at the monthly price, it’s cheaper than Amazon Music Unlimited ($9-11/month).
[Read our full guide: How to Self-Host Plex]
Migration Guide
Step 1: Download Your Purchased Music
If you purchased MP3s or AutoRip albums from Amazon, download them:
- Go to Amazon Music Settings → Download My Music
- Download all purchased tracks (these are DRM-free MP3s, typically 256 kbps)
- Check your AutoRip library — CDs purchased from Amazon often include free digital copies
Amazon Music Unlimited streams cannot be downloaded. They’re DRM-protected. You’ll need to re-acquire these from other sources.
Step 2: Upgrade Your Collection Quality
Amazon purchases are typically 256 kbps MP3 — decent but not lossless. Consider upgrading key albums:
- Bandcamp — FLAC downloads, support artists directly
- CD ripping — Use dBpoweramp or EAC for lossless FLAC rips
- HDTracks / Qobuz — Hi-res FLAC downloads
Step 3: Organize Files
/music/
├── Artist Name/
│ └── Album Name (Year)/
│ ├── 01 - Track Title.flac
│ └── cover.jpgUse MusicBrainz Picard for automatic tagging and organization.
Step 4: Deploy Navidrome
One container, one command, your music is streaming.
Step 5: Set Up Mobile Access
Install a Subsonic-compatible app:
- Android: Symfonium, Ultrasonic
- iOS: play:Sub, Amperfy
- Web: Navidrome’s built-in player
Cost Comparison
| Amazon Music (Prime) | Amazon Music Unlimited | Self-Hosted (Navidrome) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $15/mo (Prime bundle) | $9-11/mo (+ Prime) | $0 |
| Annual cost | $180/year | $108-132/year (+ Prime) | $0 |
| 5-year cost | $900 | $540-660 (+ $900 Prime) | ~$50 (electricity) |
| Audio quality | HD (up to 16/44.1) | Ultra HD (up to 24/192) | Your source quality |
| Catalog size | 100M+ songs | 100M+ songs | Your collection |
| Alexa integration | Deep | Deep | None (or limited via AirPlay) |
| Offline mode | Yes | Yes | Yes (client download) |
| Ad-free | With Prime | Yes | Yes |
| Privacy | Amazon tracking | Amazon tracking | Complete privacy |
| Cancel impact | Lose streaming | Lose streaming | Keep everything |
What You Give Up
- Alexa voice control. “Alexa, play [song]” doesn’t work with self-hosted music. You can use AirPlay or Bluetooth to stream to Echo devices, but voice commands won’t control your library.
- 100+ million song catalog. Self-hosting limits you to your own collection. New music requires purchasing or acquiring it.
- Curated playlists and stations. Amazon’s editorial playlists and algorithm stations require a streaming catalog.
- Ultra HD / Spatial Audio convenience. Amazon delivers hi-res audio automatically if available. Self-hosting requires you to source hi-res files yourself.
- Cross-device sync with Amazon ecosystem. Seamless playback across Echo, Fire TV, and mobile devices. Self-hosted alternatives work across devices but require more setup.
- AutoRip. Amazon automatically adds digital copies of purchased CDs to your library. This convenience goes away.
What you gain: No subscription fees, true file ownership, privacy, no quality tier confusion, and freedom from Amazon’s ecosystem.
FAQ
Can I play self-hosted music on Echo devices?
Yes, via Bluetooth or AirPlay (if your Echo supports it). You won’t get Alexa voice control for your library, but you can stream audio from your phone’s Subsonic client to the Echo like any other Bluetooth speaker.
Are Amazon MP3 purchases good enough quality?
Amazon sells 256 kbps VBR MP3s — perfectly listenable but not lossless. For critical listening, consider upgrading key albums to FLAC from Bandcamp, HDTracks, or CD rips.
What if I only use Amazon Music because it’s “free” with Prime?
That’s the Prime trap — you’re paying for it whether you use it or not. If you rarely use Amazon Music, self-hosting with Navidrome costs nothing extra and gives you a better experience for music you actually own.
Should I cancel Prime just for music?
Probably not — evaluate Prime holistically (shipping, video, photos). But if music is a significant reason you keep Prime, and you have your own collection, self-hosting removes that dependency.
Related
Get self-hosting tips in your inbox
New guides, comparisons, and setup tutorials — delivered weekly. No spam.